Skip Navigation

  1. About Us
    1. Overview
    2. History
    3. Recognition
    4. Offices
  2. Our Practice
    1. Practice Areas
      1. Patents, Utility Models, and Industrial Designs
      2. Trademarks
      3. Copyrights
      4. Corporate, Commercial and Business Law
      5. IP Litigation, Alternative Dispute Resolution
      6. Regulatory Law
      7. Licensing, Tech Transfer & Franchising
      8. Anti-Piracy, Anti-Counterfeiting & Enforcement
    2. Industry Groups
      1. Media, Sports & Entertainment Law Group
      2. Life Science & Pharmaceutical Law Group
  3. Our People
    1. Partners
      1. Sergio L. Olivares, Sr. † (1931-2010)
      2. Sergio L. Olivares, Jr.
      3. Luis C. Schmidt
      4. Cesar Ramos, Jr.
      5. Antonio Belaunzaran
      6. Gustavo A. Alcocer
      7. Jose Ignacio De Santiago
      8. Alejandro Luna
      9. Alonso Camargo
      10. Daniel Sanchez
    2. Associates (A - M)
      1. Osvaldo Amaral
      2. Armando Arenas
      3. Sofía Arroyo
      4. Guillermo Ballesteros
      5. Varinia Calleros
      6. Abraham Diaz
      7. Georgina Flores
      8. Pedro Herrera
      9. Carlos Maya
    3. Associates (N - Z)
      1. Mauricio Narváez
      2. Víctor Ramírez
      3. Sergio Rangel
      4. Maria del Carmen Sada
      5. Juan Luis Serrano
      6. Guillermo Treviño
      7. Carlos Woodworth
    4. All Attorneys / Engineers
    5. Firm Administration
  4. Knowledge & Resources
    1. Articles
      1. Trademark Law Articles
        1. Use requirements
        2. Approach to composite marks changed, again
        3. Life Sciences Handbook 2011 - Country Q&A
        4. Mexico should accept secondary meaning
        5. Getting the Deal Through - Trademarks 2011
        6. Pharmaceutical Trademarks 2010/2011 - A Global Guide
        7. No legal basis for banning names derived from INNs
        8. How Latin America tackles cutting-edge IP issues
        9. Specialised IP court corrects IMPI
        10. Protecting trade dress
        11. 43 more items...
      2. Patent Law Articles
        1. Getting the Deal Through - Patents 2012
        2. Surge of Patent Application Final Rejections Provides Unique Opportunity for Patent Precent Making
        3. Mexico issues regulations to approve biologic drugs
        4. Latin America Roundtable
        5. New regulations pending
        6. The International Comparative Guide
        7. Marketing authorization for pharmaceutical
        8. Approval of follow-on biologics in Mexico
        9. Mexican Linkage Gazette April 2011
        10. Patent Prosecution Highway in Mexico
        11. 37 more items...
      3. Copyright Law Articles
        1. Advertising in social media networks
        2. Technology challenges digital rights
        3. Exceptions to copyright protection and the permitted uses of copyright works in the hi-tech and digital sectors
        4. Derechos sobre producción audiovisual
        5. How Latin America tackles cutting-edge IP issues
        6. Copyright Litigation 2010
        7. Legislation and enforcement - Copyrights 2010
        8. Valuing folklore
        9. Protecting novel ideas
        10. Mexico's fair use balancing act
        11. 100 more items...
      4. Corporate Law Articles
        1. Mexico issues Personal Data Protection Rules
        2. How data affects innovation
        3. A practical cross-border
        4. New registry for security interests
        5. The International Comparative Legal Guide to: Merger Control 2011
        6. The International Comparative Legal Guide to: Merger Control 2010
        7. Due diligence issues to consider in M&A
        8. Income expectations in licensing
        9. The reasons for valuation
        10. Amendments proposed to franchise regulation
      5. IP Litigation, ADR Articles
        1. Scope of new specialised courts widened
        2. Reform of preliminary injunctions
        3. Mexican Patent Office excludes Formulation Patents from Linkage Gazette
        4. Mexico gets ready to approve biocomparable drugs
        5. Mexico's hotel for the stars highlights power in the name
        6. Supreme Court upholds the worth of formulation patents
        7. Getting the Deal Through - Patents 2010
        8. Getting the Deal Through Trademarks 2010
        9. Trademark enforcement
        10. Venues for appealing IMPI decisions
        11. 15 more items...
      6. Regulatory Law Articles
        1. Recent amendment to the Federal Law for Consumer Protection
        2. Amendments to the Federal Law for Consumer Protection
        3. Mexico issues Personal Data Protection Rules
        4. New Regulations Pending
        5. Marketing authorization for pharmaceutical products to foreign applicants
        6. Data Package Exclusivity (DPE)
        7. Supreme Court upholds the worth of formulation patents
        8. Pharmaceutical trademarks
        9. Framework for biotherapeutic products established
        10. Pharmaceutical Advertising 2009
        11. 4 more items...
      7. Licensing, Tech Transfer Articles
        1. Creating a secure franchise system
      8. Anti-Piracy, Anti-Counterfeiting Articles
        1. New register against counterfeits
        2. Beat the counterfeiters in Mexico
        3. Battling counterfeits through Customs
        4. Getting the Deal Through Trademarks 2010
        5. Enforcing plant variety rights in Mexico
        6. Pharmaceutical Trademarks 2009
        7. Internet Issues
        8. Anti-counterfeiting 2009
        9. Vegetal variety rights enforced
        10. New Customs rules lead to seizures
        11. 3 more items...
      9. Media, Sports & Entertainment Focused Articles
        1. Advertising in social media networks
        2. Whither Rental Rights?
        3. Improved protection for personalities
      10. Life Sciences Focused Articles
        1. Latin America Roundtable
        2. New regulations pending
        3. The International Comparative
        4. Approval of follow-on biologics in Mexico
        5. Global Pharmaceutical Linkage Regulations:
        6. Life Sciences Handbook 2011 - Country Q&A
        7. Supreme Court upholds the worth of formulation patents
        8. Repercussions expected on medicine advertising campaign in Mexico
        9. Framework for biotherapeutic products established
        10. Pharmaceutical Trademarks 2009
        11. 1 more item...
    2. Webinar Archive
      1. Webinar - Changes to Mexican Patent and Healthcare Laws for Life Sciences
      2. Webinar - Digital Rights Issues in Copyright Law
      3. Webinar - Data Package Exclusivity Rights in Latin America
    3. Recognition
    4. News
      1. Mexico subscribes Madrid Protocol
      2. Presumed Guilty - How can a law firm help win an Emmy?
      3. New rules came in force to speed timeframes in administrative appeal proceedings
      4. Recent reforms to the Mexican Industrial Property Law dealing with trademark priority rights
      5. Olivares & Cia. ranking
      6. Data Package Exclusivity (DPE)
      7. Mr. Sergio Olivares Sr's Passing
      8. Pharma Linkage Regulations Supreme Court Decision
      9. Managing IP magazine has recognized Olivares & Cia. as the leading firm for patent work in Mexico
      10. Mexican Congress amends the Patent Law
      11. 1 more item...
  5. Events
  6. Offices
  7. Contact Us
  8. Quick guide to Mexico’s regulatory system
    1. Patent regulatory overview
    2. Trademark regulatory overview
    3. Copyright regulatory overview
    4. Corporate & Commercial Regulatory overview

Home » Knowledge & Resources » Articles » Patent Law Articles » Proving patent infringement

Proving patent infringement

By Alejandro Luna, Partner
Managing Intellectual Property, International Briefings, July/August 2002
The Mexican Industrial Property Law (IPL) grants a patentee the right for the exclusive exploitation of the patented invention. Therefore, the patent gives the right to exclude others from making, using, offering for sale or importing the covered invention. Briefly, in a patent infringement action the plaintiff must prove the following:
  • Ownership or recorded licence over a granted, valid and fully in force patent. Generally, a certified copy of the file wrapper of the patent prosecution is enough to prove these requirements. However, the defendant may challenge the validity of the patent.
  • That someone uses, manufactures, sells, or imports the patented invention. The Mexican IPL establishes direct infringement over the manufacturer. However, infringement against sellers requires evidence of prior notice of the alleged infringement. When the plaintiff claims infringement of a patented process, the defendant has the burden of proving the use of a different process. There are no grounds in the IPL to apply contributory infringement doctrine, namely action against persons who assist in patent infringement.
  • The use of the patented invention. Pursuant to the Mexican IPL only literal infringement is recognized, no infringement under the doctrine of equivalence is provided. The plaintiff should prove that the wording of the patent’s claim of claims covers the alleged infringer’s product or process.
First, the plaintiff must define the scope of the approved claims. The IPL provides that the breadth of the claims is determined by the wording, aided by the description and drawings.
Interpretation of the claims and the use of the patented invention in the accused product or process are technical issues. Therefore, infringement actions require proof from experts even though the corresponding Technical Center of the Mexican PTO may render a technical report as an expert in patent matters.
The burden of proving authorization is on the defendant. The doctrine of implied licence has never been tested before the Mexican courts.
Finally, proving patent infringement in Mexico is a difficult task in a country that follows a strict civil law system of formalistic rules for both evidence and proceedings.